A 'non-definition' refers to a statement, concept, or description that fails to provide a clear, precise, and universally accepted meaning of a term or concept. It may lack essential components of a definition, such as necessary and sufficient conditions, distinguishing characteristics, or a clear scope. It often employs vague language, circular reasoning, or relies on subjective interpretations, rendering the term ambiguous or misunderstood. A non-definition doesn't establish boundaries, allowing for varied and often conflicting interpretations of the described idea. It obscures more than clarifies, hindering effective communication and critical analysis.
Non-definition meaning with examples
- When asked for a definition of 'love,' the response 'Love is what you feel when you love' is a non-definition. It lacks clarity and utilizes the defined term within its explanation, offering no concrete understanding. It offers circular reasoning. This unhelpful response offers a vague understanding which would lead to further inquiry and confusion as to the nature of love.
- Describing 'justice' as 'fairness, sometimes' falls into the category of a non-definition. This statement is exceedingly vague. It doesn't specify *how* something is fair nor the conditions under which it applies. It relies on a subjective concept lacking clear criteria. Without specificity, its meaning shifts dependent on context and the perspective of whoever interprets this sentence.
- Defining 'art' as 'something creative' is a non-definition because it's overly broad and imprecise. Creativity alone is not a defining trait of art, and almost anything could potentially be deemed creative. This definition doesn't differentiate art from non-art or establishes boundaries, leaving the meaning open to near unlimited interpretation. The scope and clarity are poor.
- The statement, 'Truth is truthiness' (used by Stephen Colbert) serves as a non-definition. It employs a nonsensical, made-up word and fails to explain what truth *is*. It bypasses any attempt to define truth. This is a satirical example, intended to mock a lack of true definition, while the lack of definition remains.